Blogs

Yellow, Black or Red Tongkat Ali: Which is the best for you?

Still looking for that perfect Tongkat Ali on Amazon? Or are you comparing Yellow vs Black Tongkat Ali, or Yellow vs Red Tongkat Ali and deciding which one is the best?

Hold on to your thoughts for a second. There are few things that you need to know before choosing the right brand of Tongkat Ali.

Getting the right herbal supplement can be a daunting task, let alone weaving through a sea of information on the internet. Notwithstanding the enormous marketing hype and glorified health promises from Tongkat Ali, you definitely want the best for your health.

In this article, we perform our assessment on various types of Tongkat Ali roots that form the majority of brands that are currently sold in the market today. There are three types of Tongkat Ali roots from different plants:

  • Yellow Tongkat Ali – Eurycoma Longifolia
  • Black Tongkat Ali – Polyalthia Bullata
  • Red Tongkat Ali – Stema Tuberosa

Yellow, Black or Red Tongkat Ali. How do you know which type of Tongkat Ali root is best suited for you?

Assessment Criteria

To answer that, we performed an objective evaluation based on six criteria. Our assessment is based on the score of 1-5 (Low to Very High) and each criterion is explained below:

1. Popularity – how popular based on the number of products sold in the market (including online-platforms), number of social media mentions, search enquiries and media coverage.

2. Availability – Are these raw herbs widely available from where it is sourced or the country of origin? How easy to obtain these herbs? Are there restrictions imposed for exporting the herb outside the country of origin?

3. Potency – The level of effectiveness of the herb on your body as claimed by suppliers and customer feedback. The potency is largely based on either traditional methods (eg: boiling, heat-dried) or advance extraction technologies (eg: freeze-dried, etc)

4. Proven Benefits – The estimated number of potential or proven health benefits that you will gain based on credible sources such as scientific studies, clinical trials and research publications.

5. Research Publications – Is the herb widely used as samples in research or scientific studies (this is based on the volume of papers published to date).

6. Health Risks – How safe is the herb to your health given the ingredients, content and side-effects?  We also investigate the level of mercury and lead contained in each herb, which may be detrimental to your health or cause kidney failure.

So let’s take a look at the facts and our top pick!

Yellow Tongkat Ali

Plant Name: Eurycoma Longifiolia

Yellow Tongkat Ali comes from a plant known as Eurycoma Longifolia. The plant grows naturally in remote rainforests of Malaysia, Indonesia and some smaller parts of Southern Thailand. The commercialization into the world of natural herbs took place since early 2000s, led by the Malaysian Government – making it one of the key industries in Malaysia today.

Fast forward, majority of the Tongkat Ali sold in the market today comes from yellow Tongkat Ali which are harvested widely in Malaysia. This is the most widely researched Tongkat Ali with more than 100 published papers to date as the potential health benefits continued to attract scientists from around the world. We have compiled 12 potential scientific-backed health benefits here.

Yellow Tongkat Ali has the most bitter taste compared to red or black Tongkat Ali variants. The reason of its extreme bitterness is due to the high level of eurycomanone – a key marker to measure potency level of Tongkat Ali.

Eurycomanone is the prominent bioactive quassinoid present in Tongkat Ali – widely proven by scientists to increase testosterone whilst exhibiting anti-inflammatory and anti-bacterial properties.

Yes, check out the ingredient in the brand of Tongkat Ali – does it say Eurycoma Longifolia? If yes, than it is definitely Yellow Tongkat Ali.

Here is our final verdict:

Popularity
4/5
Availability
5/5
Potency
4.5/5
Proven Benefits
4/5
Research Publications
4/5
Health Risks
1/5

Black Tongkat Ali

Plant Name : Polyalthia Bullata

Black Tongkat Ali comes from a plant known as Polyalthia bullata with a small root at 2-3 cm in diameter, which is significantly smaller diameter than yellow Tongkat Ali. Also known as Wild Black Gorilla or Tongkat Ali Baginda, the Black Tongkat Ali is found in alongside rivers in lowland forest of Peninsular Malaysia such in the state of Pahang.

How does it taste like? Black Tongkat Ali smells fishy (perhaps due to the location where it is generally found – i.e near the river), but generally tastes less bitter than Yellow Tongkat Ali.

Production of Black Tongkat Ali is rare although it is found to be exported in raw slices. While its healing efficacy is touted to be much better than Yellow Tongkat Ali, it is traditionally used by the indigenous as a natural aphrodisiac for men’s health. Therefore, it’s popularity is contained within Asia.

Beyond it’s only health claim, there was lack of research or published papers associated with Black Tongkat Ali found to date. This makes it less popular amongst those seeking for scientific validation and proof of its health benefits.

At the same time, we found no-approval by the Malaysian Health Drugs Authorities on Tongkat Ali products sold in pharmacies that carries the title “Black Tongkat Ali”. Could the high level of mercury and soil-borne lead found in Black Tongkat Ali be the reason behind this ban?

Here is our final verdict:

Popularity
3/5
Availability
2/5
Potency
4/5
Proven Benefits
2/5
Research Publications
0/5
Health Risks
3.7/5

Red Tongkat Ali

Plant Name : Stema Tuberosa

Now this Red Tongkat Ali or Malaysian Red Ginseng comes from a scientific plant known as Stema Tuberosa. This comes from a species known as Jackiopsis Ornate from the family of Rubaceae. This rare tree is found growing along rivers, sandy or swampy soil in virgin rainforests up to 400 metres altitude in Peninsular Malaysia.

The plant is similar to Stemona Tuberosa is also found in remote parts of China, Indonesia and Thailand. The root has it’s name due to its distinct strong red colour and after drying, usually it turns into light red. This root is also known by other name such as Akar Haji Samat by locals.

The only reason why it continued to be popular amongst locals is the acceptable taste.  The Red Tongkat Ali smells and taste like any ginseng. It can taste somewhat sweet, a total opposite compared to Yellow and Black Tongkat Ali. It also means that the level of eurycomanone is the lowest in the Red Tongkat Ali.

Has there been any research or scientific evidence done on Red Tongkat Ali to validate its health benefits? After hours of researching, we have found none! Most of the Tongkat Ali clinical trials and scientific studies were based on Eurycoma Longifolia (i.e Yellow Tongkat Ali).

The red ginseng is consumed as regular herbal tea or coffee to give a dose of energy by the Chinese. We cannot ascertain the level of lead or mercury in red ginseng, but it is believed to be safe as it is widely sold in raw slices (instead of capsules).

Aside from this, we did not find any approved brands sold in pharmacies that carries “Red Tongkat Ali” title. Due to lower acceptance and trust, perhaps you should consider twice from buying it from Amazon stores!

Here is our final verdict:

Popularity
4/5
Availability
3.5/5
Potency
3/5
Proven Benefits
3/5
Research Publications
1/5
Health Risks
2/5

Our Top Pick

Tongkat Ali has been in the market for almost 20 years now, but every now and again, we have customers looking for an objective evaluation to assess these roots. And that is the reason we chose to publish this article. We aim to assist millions of people to choose the right herbal product(s) to revitalize their health.   

Our clear winner is the Yellow Tongkat Ali due to high scores in every criteria described above. It was initially a challenge to pick the best as all types of Tongkat Ali will bring different benefits. But judging against criteria such as potency, proven benefits and health risks, Yellow Tongkat Ali won hands down.

Here is the list of 20+ trusted Tongkat Ali brands that use Yellow Tongkat Ali. You may find it useful to compare prices and potency.

With quality, you can feel a difference. Click here to find out more on quality.

Stay healthy and don’t forget to choose the best.

Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on linkedin
LinkedIn
Share on whatsapp
WhatsApp

Disclaimer: Content published in this article is not intended to promote any brands nor to provide any form of recommendations to purchase or consume medication, drugs or herbal supplement brands directly or indirectly. By reading this, the sole responsibility and decision lies on the reader to perform their own assessment and / or to arrive at an informed decision based on publicly available information. By reading the content published on this website means you are aware on the risks involved in purchasing any of the products or brands mentioned in this article. We highly recommend you and the readers to consult your nearest doctor before making any purchase from this website or any other websites or social platforms after reading this article.

Share this post

Share on facebook
Share on google
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on pinterest
Share on print
Share on email

Related Posts

7 Responses

  1. This is good information on tangkat ali. I am physically active guy. A business owner, a husband and a father to a 3 and 5 yr old that demand a lot of energy. About last year or so, i started dropping in T levels which a blood test confirmed it. So, the hunt for an alternative to testosterone replacement begins. After spending a lot of time researching, i discovered tongkat ali but had no idea what it is about because i never consume or bought it. This article really helps people like me to understand more about tongkat ali. I now understand the types of tongkat ali and the differences in benefit, health risk and potency. Thank you!

  2. Great article! I have been consuming tongkat ali for the past few years, and I can really say that it really improve my overall health and well-being. Previously, I never knew that were so many different types of tongkat ali. This article is an eye-opening. Just found out that the tongkat ali products that i have been consuming were the high-quality yellow tongkat ali Eurycoma Longifolia, which explain why it tasted very bitter when I mixed the powder in my coffee. Really intrigued to try this product in capsule forms!

  3. Always wondered why there is yellow tongkat ali everywhere. But, its uncommon to find or even heard about the black and the red tongkat ali. My assumption is that the other 2 type is very rare to get and that is why its hard to get. never expected the black one is banned. Thanks to this article, i now understand the difference between the 3 types of tongkat ali. Kind of interested to get red tongkat ali and maybe make tea or coffee and see how it taste.

  4. I am a very active guy in early 40’s. I tried pretty much every natural testosterone booster supplement out there to increase health and performance: tribulus terrestris, Yohimbe, horny goat weed, ginseng, Ashwagandha… you name it.

    I didnt knew there was 3 types of tongkat ali and the black one was banned due to its high level of mercury.

    Tongkat ali is one of the few supplements for men I tried that actually works for me.I am feeling leaner and stronger. My overall sense of well being and confidence is way up. There is a very noticeable difference between the days I am taking tongkat ali vs the days that I don’t. Overall, I highly recommend this product to anyone looking to get better workouts, perform better in bed or simply feel better and more enthusiastic about life in general.

    Thanks for the informative website!

  5. It is interesting to know that some of tongkat ali is harmfull to the body such as black tongkat ali. I never know about this before. Luckily its production is rare in the market. Yellow tongkat ali or Eurycoma Longifolia is the most common type that i have seen in the market.

  6. As a millennial who is interested in the efficacy of modern Western medicine, I can’t deny that I’m at least a little bit curious about tongkat ali. Although I’m a bit sceptical about it, I do feel some differences when started consuming akar ali for the past three weeks. While I fully understand that it might work differently from person to person, I feel less lethargic. But the most important thing is that I don’t experience any side effect from it so far.

  7. Before i found out about tongkat ali, i’ve been noticing that i’m constantly tired and having a hard time to stay concentrate or focus for long. Within a few weeks of consuming tongkat ali, i noticed that i’m a lot more focus, didn’t get tired easily and feeling a lot less weary. Due to the extra energy i’ve gained, i started to hit the gym for some cardio and weight lifting and noticed i had done more reps than i previously could. I even felt more motivated, but it could just be me. Haha. Overall, tongkat ali works for me and didn’t give me any negative side effects.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *